72 Spirituality Studies 2.1 Jīva: The Sentient Substance as Karmic Agent Among the six fundamental substances, jīva occupies a central place in Jain soteriology, for it is the only substance understood, within Jain ontology, to possess consciousness and thereby function as the locus of bondage and liberation. Umāsvāti (1994, 39) defines the essential characteristic of the soul as follows: upayogo lakṣaṇam (Tattvārtha Sūtra 2:8) – Sentience is the defining characteristic of the soul. Here, Tatia renders upayoga as “sentience”; this study uses “sentience” and “consciousness” interchangeably to denote the soul’s intrinsic cognitive capacity. The term upayoga (Sa. “sentience” or “conscious engagement”) denotes the active manifestation of consciousness, encompassing “knowledge” (Sa. jñāna) and “perception” (Sa. darśana). Within Jain ontology, consciousness is not conceived as an emergent property arising from material complexity, nor as a temporary state that the soul acquires and loses. Rather, it is an essential “quality” (Sa. guṇa) that eternally characterizes sentient substances and distinguishes them from non-sentient substances. In Jain ontology, the soul is thus an autonomous “substance” (dravya) whose essential “qualities” (guṇa) include “knowledge” (jñāna), “perception” (darśana), “bliss” (Sa. sukha), and “energy” (Sa. vīrya). These qualities are ontologically enduring and constitute what the soul is. Even in bondage, these qualities remain present, though their manifestation is conditioned (Mehta 1998, 188–189). Jain thought affirms the irreducible plurality of souls, grounding moral responsibility in enduring individual identity. Even in liberation, when all karmic obscuration is removed, liberated souls retain their distinct identity while fully manifesting their intrinsic qualities (Mehta 1998, 109–110). This metaphysical commitment provides the basis for Jain emphasis on personal moral responsibility: bondage and liberation are neither transferable nor externally bestowed. These ontological commitments have important causal implications within Jain philosophy. Karmic agency, in this context, refers to the soul’s capacity to initiate “activity” (Sa. yoga) –of mind, speech, and body – and thereby incur karmic consequences. Here yoga denotes the technical Jain sense of activity that enables interaction with matter and produces “karmic influx” (Sa. āsrava) (Umāsvāti 1994, 149–151), rather than later yogic postures or meditative techniques. Because jīva alone is held to possess consciousness and engage in activity, it functions as the bearer of karmic agency. Moral responsibility is thus grounded in the soul’s autonomous agency rather than in divine command. If karmic responsibility is grounded in an enduring, autonomous soul whose essential capacities persist across lifetimes, this raises the question of whether mechanisms that are purely moral or psychological are sufficient to account for how karmic consequences attach, persist, and are removed, thereby pointing toward the need for an ontologically durable causal substrate. Addressing this requirement necessitates examining pudgala, the non-sentient substance through which karmic bondage becomes materially operative. 2.2 Pudgala: The Non-Sentient Substance and Material Condition of Bondage If the soul’s autonomous agency grounds moral responsibility, a further question arises: why is karma conceived in Jain philosophy as a material substance rather than purely moral principle, psychological disposition, or abstract metaphysical law? In Jain ontology, “matter” (Sa. pudgala) is the non-sentient substance that constitutes the physical dimension of reality and provides the ontological basis through which karmic bondage is understood to operate. Umāsvāti (1994, 126) characterizes pudgala in the Tattvārtha Sūtra by its possession of sensory qualities: sparśa-rasa-gandha-varṇāḥ pudgalasya (Tattvārtha Sūtra 5:23) – The cluster of matter and atoms have qualities of touch, taste, smell, and colour. This formulation reflects the Jain atomistic framework in which pudgala exists both as aggregates and as ultimate
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MTUwMDU5Ng==